This is part 14 of Crisis Money, a Money Outsider series about what financial crises do to our minds, and what our minds do back. It stands on its own, but part 13 covered the science of scarcity.
The research of Sendhil Mullainathan and Eldar Shafir showed that financial scarcity consumes mental capacity, a cost they called the bandwidth tax. Britain's welfare system is built as if that were not true. This part is about what happened when the tax hit almost everybody at once.
The cost-of-living squeeze
In the autumn of 2022, something happened that had not occurred in a generation. Inflation in the UK crossed 11%, the highest in 41 years. Energy bills doubled. Food prices rose by percentages that people noticed on every shopping trip. The typical annual energy bill went from around £1,200 to over £2,500 in the space of a year. Supermarket own-brand products, the usual refuge of the budget-conscious, saw price increases of 17%. And for millions of households, the bandwidth tax intensified from a chronic drain to an acute crisis.
The Money and Mental Health Policy Institute had already established the connection between financial difficulty and cognitive impairment. In their 2016 study of 5,500 people with mental health conditions, 93% reported spending more during periods of poor mental health, 92% found financial decisions harder, and 74% had delayed paying bills. The relationship runs in both directions: financial pressure worsens mental health, and poor mental health worsens financial decision-making. Each feeds the other. The researchers called it a "vicious cycle," which is one of those phrases that gets used loosely, but here it's precisely accurate. Financial difficulty reduces cognitive function, which leads to worse financial decisions, which deepens financial difficulty, which further reduces cognitive function. Without an external intervention, the cycle has no natural breaking point.
The cost-of-living crisis tightened that loop for the wider population. By mid-2023, 82% of UK adults reported being worried about the rising cost of living, and 60% said it was affecting their mental health, according to the Mental Health Foundation.1 These aren't people with pre-existing conditions or long-term poverty. They are mortgage holders watching rates triple after fourteen years of near-zero interest rates. Renters facing 20% increases with no mechanism to challenge them. Parents choosing between heating and eating, a phrase that entered common usage with unsettling speed because it described a real choice that a growing number of families were making every week.
I keep coming back to the everyday arithmetic of it. Before the crisis, a family on a median income could pay their bills on autopilot. The numbers worked. You didn't need to think about whether to buy the branded cereal or the own-brand one, whether to turn the heating on at 6pm or 7pm, whether that jacket for the school trip was affordable this month. After energy bills doubled, every one of those micro-decisions became a bandwidth problem. The cognitive load of managing a household budget increased for almost everyone. People who had never thought about the price of butter were suddenly doing mental arithmetic in supermarket aisles, calculating per-kilo costs and comparing pack sizes, the kind of cognitive work that low-income households had always done but that now spread to millions of people who were unpractised at it.
The pandemic had already primed this. The furlough scheme, which at its peak in May 2020 supported 8.9 million jobs out of 11.7 million claims, provided 80% of wages up to £2,500 a month. On paper, it prevented mass unemployment and was broadly considered one of the most effective policy responses to the pandemic anywhere in the world. In practice, the experience of being furloughed was not neutral. Research found that furloughed workers were 20 percentage points more likely to cut spending than those who remained working, even though their income loss was only 20%. The gap between the actual income reduction and the behavioural response tells us something about bandwidth. The uncertainty of the situation, not knowing when furlough would end, whether the company would survive, whether the scheme would be extended, consumed cognitive resources beyond what the raw numbers would predict.
The anxiety effects persisted long after people returned to their jobs. Being told your livelihood depends on a government scheme that might end next month, extended in increments of a few weeks at a time, is a sustained bandwidth drain. People couldn't plan. They couldn't commit to spending. They couldn't make the kind of medium-term financial decisions (fix the roof, replace the boiler, take on a new tenancy) that require confidence about the next six months.
What the cost-of-living crisis revealed is that the bandwidth tax is not a fixed property of poverty. It is a sliding scale. As financial pressure increases, cognitive capacity decreases, and this happens across the income distribution. The university lecturer whose mortgage payment has jumped by £400 a month is experiencing a version of the same mechanism as the UC claimant waiting five weeks for a first payment. The severity differs enormously, but the underlying cognitive process is the same: financial worry captures attention, narrows the tunnel, and reduces the bandwidth available for everything else.
The difference is that the university lecturer probably still has enough total bandwidth to absorb the hit. They'll worry more, sleep a bit less, and make some poorer decisions at the margin. But they have a savings buffer, an employer with a sick pay scheme, a professional network that can help if things get worse. The UC claimant, who started with less bandwidth and faces a more demanding system, has no margin left. That is where the real damage accumulates. The bandwidth tax is regressive in the same way that a flat tax is regressive: it takes the same cognitive toll regardless of how much capacity you started with, which means it costs the poorest far more than the richest in relative terms.
There is something else the cost-of-living crisis did that we're only beginning to understand. It normalised financial anxiety for a huge segment of the population. When 82% of adults report financial worry, it stops being seen as a sign that something is wrong with the individual and starts being seen as the background condition of life.2 The danger is that we adjust to it. That the bandwidth tax becomes invisible because everyone is paying it, and we stop noticing the cognitive impairment because it has become the baseline. A society that is collectively operating with reduced cognitive bandwidth will not make good collective decisions. The irony should not be lost: the thing that prevents good thinking about financial policy is the same financial pressure that the policy should address.
Designing for depleted minds
There's a separate scientific debate that feeds into all of this, and it's about whether self-control is a depletable resource. For years, the concept of "ego depletion" dominated psychology. The idea, advanced by Roy Baumeister and others, was that willpower works like a muscle: use it on one task and you have less available for the next.3 This would mean that people facing constant financial decisions are literally using up their capacity for self-control, leaving none for the long-term thinking that financial wellbeing requires.
The problem is that ego depletion has not replicated well. A major meta-analysis involving 2,141 participants found essentially no effect, and a subsequent multi-lab replication with 3,531 participants reached the same conclusion.4 The clean version of the story, where self-control is a finite fuel tank that financial pressure empties, is probably wrong. This matters because the ego depletion model was enormously influential in behavioural policy for over a decade. If the model is flawed, the policies built on it need rethinking too.
But this doesn't rescue the "poor decisions are just poor character" argument. What the scarcity research shows is something different from ego depletion. It's not that willpower runs out. It's that attention gets captured. The tunnel effect doesn't require a depleting resource. It requires a dominating concern. Financial scarcity dominates attention the way a loud noise dominates a conversation. You don't need to invoke willpower at all. The mechanism is attentional, not volitional. This is an important distinction because it changes what kind of intervention might help.
If the problem were willpower, the solution might be to simplify choices or reduce temptation (which is essentially what "nudge" policies try to do). Nudge theory, popularised by Richard Thaler and Cass Sunstein, has been hugely influential in UK policy since the formation of the Behavioural Insights Team in 2010.5 Default options, simplified forms, and strategic framing have all been deployed to help people make better choices. And they've had some successes, pension auto-enrolment being the most cited. But if the underlying problem is attentional capture by financial scarcity, nudges can only do so much. You can redesign the choice architecture all you like, but if someone's attention is locked on the electricity bill that's due on Friday, the redesigned form still won't get read. The nudge assumes you have the bandwidth to notice it. That's a questionable assumption when directed at people whose bandwidth is already fully committed to staying afloat.
The solution, according to scarcity theory, is to reduce the source of capture itself: the financial pressure. This is a very different policy prescription from "help people make better choices." It says the choices aren't really the problem. The context is the problem.
Some practical examples make this concrete. Automatic enrolment into workplace pensions works partly because it removes a decision from the bandwidth queue. You don't have to research pension providers, compare fees, calculate contribution rates, and fill in forms. You're just in. The participation rate jumped from 55% to over 90% after auto-enrolment was introduced in the UK.6 That is a bandwidth-saving design. It works because it asks nothing of the person at the moment of maximum bandwidth pressure (starting a new job, managing new expenses) and lets inertia do the work.
The five-week UC wait is a bandwidth-destroying design. It creates a financial emergency for every new claimant, which consumes cognitive resources at exactly the moment they need them most to comply with the system's requirements.
The lesson from scarcity research is not that poor people can't think. That framing would be patronising and wrong. It's that poverty creates conditions that make thinking harder for everyone, and that systems can either amplify or reduce that effect. Place a billionaire in a system that requires them to log in daily, calculate variable taper rates, and navigate a 50-page online portal while waiting five weeks with no income, and their cognitive performance would suffer too. The bandwidth tax is about context, not capability. The current welfare architecture in Britain mostly amplifies it.
Consider what a bandwidth-conscious design might look like. Payments would arrive quickly, ideally within days of a claim. Scotland's pilot of the Scottish Child Payment, which processes applications and pays out within a matter of days, shows this is administratively possible.7 The compliance requirements would be minimal during the initial period, when cognitive resources are most strained. Taper rates would be simple enough to calculate without a spreadsheet. Communications would be short, clear, and written for someone who is stressed and distracted, because that is exactly who will be reading them.
None of this is radical. It's basic user-centred design applied to a system that affects millions of lives. The private sector has understood this for years. Technology companies spend billions optimising their products for cognitive ease: reducing friction, simplifying choices, making the next step obvious. Amazon's one-click purchase exists because every additional step in a checkout process causes a percentage of customers to abandon their basket.8 The welfare system, which serves people with far less cognitive bandwidth than the average Amazon customer, imposes more friction, more complexity, and more penalties for confusion. If a private company designed an app this way, it would go out of business. But the welfare system doesn't face competition, so its users absorb the cost.
What this means for you
The bandwidth tax is something I suspect most readers will recognise, even if they've never been anywhere near a benefits office. If you've ever had a month where money was tight and found yourself unable to concentrate on anything else, unable to make decisions you'd normally handle without thinking, unable to plan beyond next week, you've felt a mild version of what Mullainathan and Shafir described. The fog that descends when the bank balance drops. The way everything else in your life seems to go slightly wrong at the same time, not because the universe is cruel but because you don't have the mental bandwidth to manage it all.
The research doesn't say you're broken. It says your brain is doing what brains do under scarcity: narrowing focus, conserving resources, prioritising the immediate threat. That's a survival mechanism, and it works well for acute dangers. Run from the lion, worry about dinner later. The problem is that modern financial pressure is chronic, not acute. The mortgage payment comes every month. The energy bill comes every quarter. The UC assessment period rolls around again before you've recovered from the last one. The tunnel never fully opens up.
There are some practical things worth knowing. First, if you're making a big financial decision during a period of high stress, you are probably operating with reduced bandwidth. That doesn't mean you shouldn't decide. It means you should be aware that your cognitive resources are stretched and, where possible, delay decisions that can wait. Sleep on it is not just folk wisdom. It is bandwidth management. If you can't delay, find someone to think alongside you, a friend, a family member, a free debt adviser at a charity like StepChange or Citizens Advice. Two minds in the tunnel see more than one.
Second, the complexity of financial products is not neutral. Every unnecessary form, every baffling fee structure, every 47-page terms-and-conditions document is a bandwidth cost. It falls heaviest on the people who can least afford it. If you're struggling to understand a financial product, the problem may not be your financial literacy. It may be that the product was designed without any consideration for the cognitive state of the person using it. The FCA's Consumer Duty, introduced in 2023, requires firms to ensure their products deliver good outcomes for customers. Whether this standard will be applied to cognitive accessibility remains to be seen, but the principle is right.
Third, be wary of judgements about other people's financial decisions. The payday loan customer, the person who didn't switch energy provider, the parent who bought the slightly more expensive school shoes because they couldn't face comparing four websites while managing three children after a ten-hour shift. These are not failures of character. They are predictable outcomes of the bandwidth tax. If you've never experienced the tunnel, you cannot know what it's like to make decisions from inside it.
The broader point is political as well as personal. Systems that are designed for people with abundant cognitive resources will fail people who don't have them, and then blame those people for the failure. Scarcity research suggests we should flip that logic: design for the most depleted user, and the system will work better for everyone. We do this for physical accessibility. Ramps help wheelchair users, but they also help parents with pushchairs and delivery drivers with trolleys. Cognitive accessibility works the same way. Simpler forms help the bandwidth-depleted, but they also help everyone else who would rather not spend forty minutes on a task that should take five.
The bandwidth tax is real. The exact size of it is debated, and honest researchers disagree about the magnitude. But the direction is clear. Financial pressure reduces the cognitive resources available for dealing with financial pressure. That is a trap, and the way out of it is not to tell people to try harder. It's to stop building systems that make the trap deeper.
The mall study lasted an afternoon. For millions of people in Britain, the experiment never ends.
Think back to those shoppers in the New Jersey mall. The ones who were told their car repair would cost $1,500 performed measurably worse on a cognitive test that had nothing to do with cars or money. They hadn't lost anything. They had merely contemplated a financial problem. Now multiply that by every bill, every rent payment, every energy price notification, sustained not for the duration of a psychology experiment but for months and years. The mall study lasted an afternoon. For millions of people in Britain, the experiment never ends.
In the next part of this series, we'll look at what happens when the bandwidth tax meets something even more corrosive: the British reluctance to talk about money at all. Because the tunnel of scarcity doesn't just narrow what you can think about. It narrows what you're willing to say out loud. Thanks for reading.
Next in this series: The British silence. If this was useful, subscribing gets you the rest of the series as it lands.
Mental Health Foundation (2023) Cost of Living and Mental Health Survey. 82% of UK adults worried mid-2023; 60% reported mental health effects.
Mental Health Foundation (2023) Cost of Living and Mental Health Survey. 82% of adults affected; 60% reported mental health effects from rising costs.
Baumeister, R.F. & Vohs, K.D. Willpower and self-control.
Hagger, M.S. et al. (2016) 'A Multilab Preregistered Replication of the Ego-Depletion Effect', Perspectives on Psychological Science, 11(4), pp. 546-573 (2,141 participants, no effect); Vohs, K.D. et al. (2021) 'A Multi-Site Preregistered Paradigmatic Test', Psychological Science, 32(10), pp. 1566-1581 (3,531 participants, same result).
Thaler, R.H. & Sunstein, C.R. (2008) Nudge. Yale University Press.
Behavioural Insights Team / DWP (2012-2025) Auto-Enrolment Evaluation. Participation rose from 55% under opt-in to over 90% under opt-out default.
Scottish Government (2021) Scottish Child Payment delivery data. Applications processed within days, compared with weeks for equivalent UK-wide benefits.
Thaler, R.H. & Sunstein, C.R. (2008) Nudge. Yale University Press. Commercial application of friction-reduction principles in choice architecture.


