This is part 16 of Crisis Money, a Money Outsider series about what financial crises do to our minds, and what our minds do back. It stands on its own, but part 15 covered money shame and the concealment tax.
Britain treats money as its last taboo. That silence does real damage to the people inside it: the shame spiral that stops people opening their bank statements, and the concealment tax they pay for hiding financial trouble. This part is about where they turn instead, and what that reveals.
There is a person in Britain who has, almost by accident, become the answer to a question most people don't consciously ask: who do I trust to talk to me about money without judging me?
In 2023, Quilter research reported by Financial Reporter found that 35% of adults aged 50 and above named Martin Lewis as their most trusted source of financial advice.1 Friends and family came second at 30%. Their own online research came third at 29%. Professional financial advisers, the people specifically trained and regulated to give financial guidance, came fourth at 22%. Bank managers, the traditional figures of financial authority, came fifth at 15%.
The Martin Lewis phenomenon is not really about Martin Lewis. It is about what his popularity reveals. A television presenter with a website is more trusted than qualified professionals, more trusted than friends and family, more trusted than people's own judgement. That is a remarkable statement about the state of financial communication in Britain.
Part of it is about accessibility. Lewis speaks in plain English, addresses real problems (how to claim a refund, which energy tariff to switch to, how to complain about a bank charge), and doesn't require you to have a prior relationship or pay a fee. But the more interesting part is about shame. Going to see a financial adviser means admitting, to another human being in a room, that you need help. It means filling in forms about your income and expenditure and watching someone else look at the numbers. For someone already in a shame spiral, that is an impossibly high barrier.
It is the financial equivalent of googling your symptoms instead of going to the doctor.
Watching Martin Lewis on television, or reading his website, costs nothing emotionally. There is no disclosure. No one knows you're doing it. No one will look at your bank statements. The advice arrives in your living room or on your phone screen without requiring you to admit anything to anyone. It is the financial equivalent of googling your symptoms instead of going to the doctor, and it serves a similar function: it allows you to seek help while maintaining the silence.
The parallel with health is closer than it might appear. The NHS has spent decades trying to get people to present earlier with symptoms, to visit the GP before the lump becomes cancer, before the chest pain becomes a heart attack. The barrier is often the same: people are afraid of what they'll be told, and the fear of knowing is stronger than the fear of not knowing. Financial shame operates identically. People know, on some level, that their debts are growing, that their pension won't be enough, that their spending is unsustainable. They don't want that knowledge confirmed by someone else, because confirmation makes it real in a way that private worry doesn't.
The FCA's Financial Lives survey data tells a related story. Around 53% of adults did not use any customer support services from their financial providers in the twelve months before the survey.2 Not because they didn't need help, but because seeking help requires disclosure. Among those who did disclose vulnerability to their financial provider, only 57% felt their provider cared about them, and only 58% said any changes were made as a result.3 For people already inclined to conceal their difficulties, this is exactly the kind of outcome that confirms the silence was the right strategy. Why tell someone about your problems if nothing changes?
The FCA also found that 7.4 million people had unsuccessfully attempted to contact one or more financial services providers in the twelve months before May 2022.4 They tried to break the silence and the system didn't pick up the phone. For people who had overcome the shame barrier to make the call in the first place, a failed contact attempt doesn't just mean they didn't get help. It means the cost of attempting to get help (the emotional energy, the vulnerability, the admission of need) was paid for nothing. Many won't try again.
This creates a strange situation in which the financial services industry simultaneously offers support that people can't bring themselves to use and fails to deliver when people do overcome the barrier. The CIPD's 2023 research on workplace financial wellbeing found that 57% of organisations said they promoted financial wellbeing to at least a moderate extent. But only 40% of employers asked employees for feedback about pay and benefits even once a year.5 The provision exists. The communication channel is broken. The silence persists on both sides: employers don't ask, employees don't tell, and the gap between provision and uptake goes unexamined.
What the Martin Lewis phenomenon tells us is that the demand for financial guidance is enormous. People are hungry for it. They just want it delivered in a way that doesn't require them to break the silence. A broadcast medium, a website, a television show: these are one-to-many communications. The person receiving the advice is anonymous. The shame barrier doesn't apply. The limitation is that one-to-many advice is necessarily generic. It can tell you how to switch your energy supplier or reclaim bank charges. It can't tell you whether your specific debt is manageable, whether your specific pension will be enough, or whether your specific anxiety about money is justified. For that, you need to talk to someone. And that is exactly what the culture prevents.
Class, crisis and the widening silence
The financial crises of the past fifteen years have interacted with the British silence in a way that has made both worse.
During austerity, the dominant political narrative was fiscal responsibility. The government needed to "tighten its belt," just as households should. This framing did something specific to the silence: it reinforced the idea that financial difficulty is a matter of personal discipline. If the nation needs to be more careful with money, and you're struggling, the implication is that you haven't been careful enough. The political framing of austerity as a household budgeting problem made it harder, not easier, for individuals to admit they were in trouble.6
The cost-of-living crisis of 2022-23 should have broken this pattern. When inflation hits 11% and energy bills double, it becomes obvious that individual budgeting is not the issue. And to some extent, the stigma did ease. Food banks became more visible and more socially acceptable. Media coverage shifted from portraying financial difficulty as a personal failing to recognising it as a systemic problem. The phrase "heating or eating" became common enough to lose its shock value.
But the shame didn't disappear. It migrated. For people who had previously considered themselves financially comfortable, the middle classes, the homeowners, the dual-income households, the experience of financial pressure was new and deeply uncomfortable. These were people whose class identity was partly built on financial competence. Admitting that the mortgage had become unmanageable or that the credit card balance was climbing was not just a financial disclosure. It was an identity threat. It meant admitting that the class position they had worked to achieve was precarious.
I've spoken to people in this situation, and what strikes me is the specificity of the silence. They'll talk about the cost-of-living crisis in general terms, as a political issue, as something happening to "people." They won't say "we cancelled the holiday because we couldn't afford it" or "I'm lying awake at 3am doing sums in my head." The general conversation about financial difficulty has become more acceptable. The personal conversation hasn't.
This produces a peculiar kind of loneliness. You know that millions of people are in the same situation because you've read it in the newspapers. But you don't know that your specific friends, your specific colleagues, your specific neighbours are experiencing it too, because nobody says so. The macro picture is clear. The micro picture remains hidden behind the same polite opacity that has always characterised British conversation about money.
The class dimension adds another layer. The Savage Great British Class Survey identified seven distinct classes in modern Britain, each with different relationships to money.7 The working-class experience of financial shame is often direct: not having enough, being visibly unable to afford things, enduring the judgements of institutions (the benefits office, the debt collector, the landlord). The middle-class experience is more about maintenance: keeping up appearances, concealing the cracks, performing a level of comfort that may not reflect reality. Both are forms of silence, but they operate through different mechanisms and produce different kinds of damage.
For the working class, the silence often delays access to help. For the middle class, it prevents acknowledgement that help is needed. Both lead to the same place: people making financial decisions in isolation, without information about what's normal, without support from their social networks, and without the reality check that comes from honest conversation.
The most feared aspect of debt is not the interest rate. It is the moment someone else finds out.
There is one more aspect of the British silence that deserves attention, and it concerns the relationship between money and morality. In British culture, unlike in many parts of the United States, there is no tradition of seeing wealth as a sign of virtue or God's favour. The British moral framework around money is different: it is not that being rich is good, but that being unable to manage your money is bad. Competence, not prosperity, is the moral standard. This means that the shame attaches not to being poor per se, but to being seen to be poor. A person quietly struggling on a modest income maintains their dignity as long as nobody knows. The moment the struggle becomes visible, the shame arrives. This is why the most feared aspect of debt is not the interest rate. It is the moment someone else finds out.
The pandemic briefly opened a window. When millions of people were furloughed simultaneously, there was a moment when financial vulnerability became a shared experience rather than a private shame. But the window closed quickly. The furlough scheme ended, the economy reopened, and the expectation of individual financial competence reasserted itself. If anything, the pandemic may have widened the silence by adding a new category of concealment: people who appeared to have weathered the storm but were quietly carrying debts accumulated during lockdown.
The silence connects back to everything else in this series. Fear is harder to manage when you can't talk about it. Herding is more powerful when you can't share independent information. The fairness instinct is harder to defend when you can't articulate what feels wrong. Narratives go unchallenged when nobody offers their own real story as a counterpoint. The bandwidth tax is heavier when you carry it alone. Each of the psychological forces this series examines is amplified by the silence, and the silence is reinforced by each of them. Shame narrows the tunnel. The tunnel deepens the shame. And the British cultural preference for not mentioning either ensures that the cycle continues undisturbed.
What this means for you
If you recognise yourself anywhere in these two pieces, if you've ever avoided opening a bill, lied about your finances to a friend, or felt a flush of shame at a checkout when a card was declined, you are in the majority. Fifty per cent of British adults consider money taboo.8 That means the silence isn't aberrant. It's the norm. The people sitting across from you at dinner, the colleagues in your office, the parents at the school gate, are statistically likely to be hiding something about their financial lives too.
There are some things worth knowing about this. First, shame thrives in isolation. Gladstone's research showed that shame drives withdrawal, and withdrawal deepens the problem.9 The single most effective thing you can do if you're in financial difficulty is to tell someone. Not necessarily a professional (though that helps). Just another human being. The act of saying it out loud, "I'm struggling," breaks the spiral. It doesn't solve the financial problem, but it removes the additional cognitive and emotional burden of concealment.
Second, the silence is not evenly distributed. It falls hardest on people who are already under the most pressure. The person on Universal Credit who is too ashamed to tell their family they've been sanctioned. The single parent who buys clothes they can't afford because they don't want their child to look different at school. The recently divorced person maintaining a lifestyle they can no longer sustain because admitting the change feels like admitting defeat. These are all rational responses to a culture that treats financial difficulty as a character flaw, but they are responses that make the underlying problem worse.
Third, if you're in a position of influence, whether as an employer, a friend, or a family member, you can change the dynamic by going first. Talk about money. Not in grand, confessional terms. Just normally. Mention that you found the energy bills stressful. Say that you've been looking at your pension and it worried you. Admit that you don't understand your mortgage terms. Each small disclosure signals to the people around you that financial uncertainty is a shared human experience, not a private failure.
The Lloyds survey found that money is more taboo than sex, religion, or politics. But taboos are not laws of nature. They are cultural constructs, maintained by collective silence and broken by collective speech. The Norwegian experiment showed that forced transparency has costs. But voluntary honesty, offered freely between people who trust each other, is different. It doesn't require a government database. It requires a willingness to be the first person to say something real.
The British silence about money costs us in ways we can quantify: delayed debt advice, underused workplace support, financial products designed for people who won't complain because they won't call. It also costs us in ways we can't quantify: the loneliness of lying awake worrying about money while believing you're the only one doing so. The shame that prevents a parent from asking for help. The marriage that collapses under the weight of undisclosed debt.
The silence is comfortable. That's why it persists. Breaking it is uncomfortable. But the evidence from every study across these two pieces points in the same direction: the cost of silence is higher than the cost of speaking.
Norway put every citizen's tax return online and discovered that transparency alone does not fix the relationship between people and money. The happiness gap widened. The comparisons multiplied. Ricardo Perez-Truglia's data showed that visibility without equality just gives people new reasons to feel worse.10 Britain's silence is the mirror image of Norway's transparency, and neither has solved the underlying problem. The question is not whether to talk about money or stay quiet. The question is whether any society has built the structures that would make honesty bearable.
In the next part of this series, we'll look at an area where the silence and the shame converge with particular force: the British relationship with property. Because if there is one financial topic where the gap between public narrative and private anxiety is widest, it is the question of whether you own your home, and what it costs you.
Next in this series: Bricks and identity. If this was useful, subscribing gets you the rest of the series as it lands.
Further reading:
Lea, S., Webley, P. & Walker, C. (1995) "Psychological Factors in Consumer Debt." Journal of Economic Psychology, 16(4), pp. 681-701. Early UK research on the psychological dimensions of debt.
Furnham, A. (2014) The New Psychology of Money. Routledge. A comprehensive treatment of money psychology with significant UK focus.
Wilkinson, R. & Pickett, K. (2009) The Spirit Level: Why Equality is Better for Everyone. Penguin. The data on how inequality affects health, wellbeing and social trust across developed nations.
Quilter (2023) 35% aged 50+ trust Martin Lewis most.
FCA (2024) Financial Lives Survey: Vulnerability and Financial Resilience. 53% did not use customer support in 12 months.
FCA (2024) Financial Lives Survey. Only 57% who disclosed vulnerability felt the provider cared; 58% said changes were made as a result.
FCA (2024) Financial Lives Survey. 7.4 million unsuccessful contact attempts with financial services providers in 12 months.
CIPD (2023) Financial Wellbeing: An Evidence Review. 57% of organisations promoted financial wellbeing; only 40% asked employees for feedback on pay and benefits once yearly.
Blyth, M. (2013) Austerity: The History of a Dangerous Idea. Oxford University Press. Analysis of how fiscal responsibility framing shifted blame from banking sector to public spending.
Savage, M. et al. (2013) A new model of social class. Sociology, 47(2), pp. 219-250.
Lloyds Banking Group (2019) 50% consider money taboo, more than sex (42%), religion (26%), politics (14%).
Gladstone, J.J. et al. (2021) Shame and financial behaviour. Journal of Consumer Research.
Perez-Truglia, R. (2020) Tax transparency and well-being. American Economic Review, 110(7).

